Blog

Black Sheep Book Club: The Fall Of Advertising and The Rise Of PR

You knew it would happen eventually. The Black Sheep have decided to start a [virtual] book club. We have a bunch of old PR and marketing books lying around, and heck, we may as well read them… again. Don’t worry – we’ll buy some new ones too. In fact, we’re taking suggestions and encouraging you guys to follow along with us! Submit your entry, we’ll make the selection, and bam! We’re a legit book club. Posts will appear every second Wednesday of the month.

Back to the point. We’re trying to get through these old books. Not because their information is relevant. It probably isn’t. But, like the time you had to read The Scarlet Letter in 11th grade, it’s more about the context and the time period when it is was written than the content itself. It helps us see how far we’ve come and how far we have to go. So, without further ado, The Fall of Advertising & the Rise of PR by Al and Laura Ries.

So here’s the thing about this book. It’s mostly wrong. But this book is kind of like a teenager. It was written in 2004 – years after advertising (and I’m talking about strictly advertising) lost its credibility, and PR was finally emerging as a progressive marketing tactic – except at this point it was taking itself too seriously and it wasn’t fully developed. This book shared about a million anecdotes about the failures of advertising campaigns, the gross amounts of money spent and the misconceptions surrounding “creativity” (which is apparently a bad thing). And yes, they listed “blimps” as alternative forms of advertising.

After railing on advertising for a good 146 pages, PR comes into the picture. The authors actually make a few valid points explaining the way PR can be used to build a brand and advertising can follow suit to boost awareness. But, they never fully accept advertising as a necessity. And, they also mandate way too many rules – including creating a celebrity spokesperson. Um, no.

But, like I said before, this book has to be taken into context. This is the era before social media surfaced in the field of marketing, before Twitter, and before anyone truly recognized the power of PR and the significance real two-way interaction with an audience – a phenomenon not possible when PR meant nothing more than press releases and newspaper articles. While they recognize the importance of establishing credibility, they don’t quite know how to make it happen without tactics as disingenuous as the advertising they claim as useless. And they certainly don’t know a thing about performance, unexpected events or viral campaigns. In fact, they describe PR as “slow moving.” Not any more, my friends.

It’s amazing to think that in 6 short years the dynamic has changed so drastically. And we’re lucky, right? We actually have the power to truly reach our customers – not bribe them, not trick them… not even beg them, but really get them to listen! We are the luckiest marketing professionals and business owners to date, and we’d be crazy not to take advantage of the opportunities at hand.

So should you read this book? Not unless you want a trip into the dark ages or a very thorough history of advertising flops. But, the lesson remains, even if it is unintentional: Our perception of marketing is only what we make of it. We have the ability to create change, be successful, and challenge ideals. Can you imagine Black Sheep back then? Your company? We don’t want to.

@ShearCreativity: